James Suckling about vintage 2017
Shine on you crazy diamonds! The top wines of the erratic 2017 vintage on the German Rhine are dazzling! (7 wines from Müller-Catoir among the Top100)
Stuart Pigott, Tasting Report, Wednesday, September 19, 2018
Herzog Rieslaner Beerenauslese 99/100 points
Herzog Rieslaner Auslese 98/100 points
***
Bürgergarten "Im Breumel" GG 98/100 points
Herzog Weissburgunder 97/100 points
Bürgergarten Muskateller 96/100 points
Herrenletten Riesling 96/100 points
Mandelring Scheurebe Spätlese 96/100 points
Mandelgarten Riesling 95/100 points
Mandelring Scheurebe 95/100 points
Herrenletten Weissburgunder 95/100 points
Bürgergarten Riesling Spätlese 95/100 points
Bürgergarten Riesling 94/100 points
***
Haardt Riesling 94/100 points
Gimmeldingen Riesling 93/100 points
Haardt Weissburgunder 93/100 points
Haardt Scheurebe 93/100 points
Haardt Muskateller 92/100 points
***
MC Riesling 92/100 points
MC Weissburgunder 92/100 points
MC Scheurebe 91/100 points
