2020: James Suckling: 91/100 "A discreet Scheurebe with restrained yellow-grapefruit and basil aromas. Very crisp and straight with an appealing lightness of touch. Crisp and refreshing finish. Should appeal to Sauvignon Blanc fans! Drink now. Screw cap."
2019: James Suckling: 92/100 "If you love New Zealand sauvignon blanc, then this dry German scheurebe may blow you mind, because it has so many of the same aromas, but is so much more juicy and has more polish at the finish, too. So joyful! From organically grown grapes. Drink now. Screw cap." | Robert Parker: 90/100 "The 2019 Scheurebe MC is crystal clear and pure in its precise and coolish fruit aromas that are reminiscent of herbs, crushed stones and green fruit. Lush and juicy but also piquant and with a fine structure on the palate, this is a highly attractive, refined and elegant Scheu with beautifully stimulating fruit and phenolic grip. Excellent and not as loud as so many Scheurebe bottlings. Tasted in April 2020 (barrel sample)"
2017: James Suckling: 91/100