Awards
2021: James Suckling: 94/100 (Best Pinot Noir in its class 2023) "Deep nose of sour cherries, damson plums and wet earth with delicate spicy oak. Fantastic interplay of restrained ripeness, good concentration and fine tannins on the impeccably balanced palate. Long velvety finish that pulls you inexorably back for more." | Wine accompaniment at the Supperclub 2023.1 for "Iberico Secreto with tomato polenta, marinated peppers and sauce mignonette" | Wine accompaniment at the Supperclub 2023.2 for "Braised beef shoulder with Ras-El-Hanout jus, cauliflower puree, roasted cauliflower, promegranate and vanilla carrots" | Ronn Wiegand (RESTAURANT WINE® Issues #216-#223, Summer 2025): 5/5 "Two wonderful 2021 Pinot Noirs from Müller-Catoir. The 2021 Neustadt 'V' is more intense and aromatic, with excellent flavor and intensity (cherry, rose petal, oak, black tea, red currant), nice balance, and a persistent finish. Still developing; likely best from 2026 on. Great value."
Awards
2019: GOURMETWELTEN Das Genussportal "Cup Deutschland Rot 2022": 91.2 points | Wine accompaniment at the Supperclub 2023 for "Pork | Polenta | Paprika"
