2020: James Suckling: 98/100 "Although the intensity of this very youthful dry riesling’s bouquet knocks you back in your seat, the ripe white-peach, tangerine and passion-fruit aromas are accompanied by a slew of delicate, floral notes. Tightly focused with diamond brightness on the concentrated yet sleek palate, this ends in a finish of breathtaking purity. From organically grown grapes. Drink or hold." | wein.plus: excellent (92 WP), top position! "Nutty and a touch of floral pomaceous and stone fruit scent with citrus notes, mineral hints and a hint of red berries. Ripe, firm, juicy fruit, fine acidity, some handle, herbal, delicate floral and again red berry aromas, clear minerality , again nutty notes in the background, certain depth, very good, firm, juicy finish with very light ethereal notes." | WEINWISSER (Giuseppe Lauria): 17/20 (excellent, with its own style) "A very beautiful, already drinkable composition with clear and typical Riesling fruit, with citrus, apple and apricot dominating." | FINE Riesling List 2020: selected as one of the best dry Grand Crus 2020
2019: James Suckling: 98/100 (TOP 100 WINES OF GERMANY 2020) "Like the first rosebud of the season that has fully colored, but is only just beginning to open up, this is full of promise. Densely packed with minerals and positive tannins that are neatly wrapped in creaminess from lees contact, this is locked into its own time frame. You really need to give it a lot of air for the mirabelle, nectarine and mandarin notes to emerge. Then there’s a stunning interplay of fruit and structure through the long, very complete finish. From organically grown grapes. Better after 2021." | Robert Parker: (92-93)/100 "The 2019 Bürgergarten "Im Breumel" Riesling GG is deep, clear and pure on the aromatic, elegant and mineral nose with its ripe and concentrated aromas of yellow stone fruit. Fullbodied, round and juicy on the silky-textured palate, this is an intense Im Bremen with stewed mirabelle aromas on the !nish. Very elegant and with fine tannins, this is a wine to keep.Tasted as a sample in April 2020." | WEINWISSER: 18/20 (great) | Eichelmann: "The dry part of the collection is once again clearly led by the Riesling "Im Breumel", the wine shows herbal, stony notes and clear yellow fruit in the bouquet, also has a lot of fruit on the palate, pineapple, green apple, lime, is powerful, salty-stimulating and sustainable."
2018: Lobenberg: 100/100 "Almost puristical, but highly intense, all on European fruit, no exoticism, fine extract sweetness, totally fermented but still with fine sweetness in the core. Very idiosyncratic in this purism, unique." | James Suckling: 97/100 "Very floral with pretty herbal undertones, ranging from coriander to dill to mint. The flowers range from jasmine to honeysuckle to almond blossom. Understated and elegant from the outset. The palate has a very chalky feel to the texture with overlapping, firm lines of acidity and dainty citrus fruit. Immaculately ironed-out edges and well-defined, linear crease. Drink now or hold." (Top 100 Wines of Germany 2019) | Robert Parker: 93+/100 "White-golden in color, pure, fine, deep and intense on the palate, the 2018 Bürgergarten "Im Breumel" GG is intense, concentrated and generous on the nose. The palate is pure, very intense and ripe as well as powerful but refined and concentrated. Very elegant and salty, with grip and tension." | RESTAURANT WINE® Issues #190-193: 5/5 stars "Exceptional GG: fleshy in texture, concentrated, and full bodied, this is refined in flavor (pear, guava, white peach, lime, pineapple), very well balanced, and full and long on the finish. Wonderful quality; warrants 5+ more years of aging. Organic. [2024-2028]"
2017: James Suckling: Stand back for the arrival of a giant! 98/100 | Weinwirtschaft "Weintest Großes Gewächs": A first-class vintage! 92/100 | Weinwisser: 17.5/20 (excellent) | restaurantwine (Ronn Wiegand): 5/5 stars - "Delicious GG Riesling from this single parcel. It is full bodied, both intense and fine in aroma/flavor (white peach, lime, honeysuckle, sage, honey), crisp and well balanced, and very persistent on the finish. Can be aged."
2016: James Suckling: 96/100 | Antonio Galloni: 93/100 | Best of riesling 2018: 92/100 | Restaurant wine (Ronn Wiegand): 5/5 stars | Finalist "Vinum Riesling-Champion 2018"
2015: Robert Parker: 95/100 | James Suckling: 95/100 "..has a finesse that makes it stand out in the strong field of the 2015 riesling GGs from the Pfalz. " | Riesling.de: 91/100
2014: Robert Parker: 93+/100 | enos/ENO WorldWine: third place of Riesling-Challenge 2016 (5/5 stars "premium wine of international standing") | James Suckling: 94/100
2013: Robert Parker: 92/100
2012: Effilee, Riesling Challenge 2014, Top 10, 5/5 stars ("premium wine of international standing")
2009: Gault Millau/Eichelmann/WeinPlus, 92-94 points | Eno Worldwine, challenge "Großes Gewächs Germany 2009", winner of tasting ("dream wine!")
2008: Le Point „Best Riesling Pfalz“ | Winespectator, 94 points „highly recommended“
2007: Weinwelt, 95 Punkte „ranks among the best white wines of the world“ | Robert Parker 94/100
2005: Bunte Wine Award, first place „Best white wine Germany“