2022: James Suckling: 97/100 (Best Riesling Spätlese 2023) "A super-elegant riesling Spatlese with extremely fine peachy fruit that wraps its tendrils around you and won’t let go. So deep and precise with a pronounced salty minerality that drives the extremely long and focused finish, dazzling the senses and the mind. Built for the long haul!"
2018: James Suckling: 94/100 Points "Crushed dill and coriander meet with bright citrus, loquats and pears. Only off-dry and very balanced with a well-judged component of acidity doing wonders for the mineral, expressive finish. Dialed-in and beautiful to drink now, but better to cellar for a decade. Drink now." | RESTAURANT WINE® Issues #190-193: 4+/5 stars "An exceptional Spätlese, this 2018 Burgergarten is round, light medium bodied, and fairly rich; a wine with refined character (pear, white peach, pineapple, lime, honeydew melon), good balance, and a very long, lingering finish. Delicious; warrants further aging. Aged in stainless steel. Organic."
2017: James Suckling: 95/100 | Finalist "Vinum Riesling-Champion 2018"
2016: James Suckling: 94/100 | Finalist vinum Riesling Champion 2017 | Wein-Plus: 90/100 | Antonio Galloni (vinous): 92/100
2014: Robert Parker: 92/100
2013: Finalist Vinum "Riesling-Champion"
2012: Harpers, UK: Top 50 German Wines 2014
2008: Robert Parker: 94/100
2007: Robert Parker: 92/100 | Riesling-Spätlesereiter-Pokal Fulda, first place
2005: WineSpectator: 93/100
2004: Robert Parker: 95/100